I’m currently playing around with a third person controller setup, and would like to try a different way of controlling the character - one that feels right for my game. There’s nothing unusual about the game, it’s just a normal third person person to be moved around, I just want to give it a different feel. Typical third person controls feel too twitchy, and Resident Evil tank style controls feel way too clumsy.
At the moment, I have a thumbstick (using a PS3 controller to test) directing the character’s gaze/camera, and the right trigger moving them in the direction they are looking.
I intend to have them walk when the trigger is pressed softly, and run as it is pressed fully.
I’d like to know if anyone has any ideas about incorporating strafing/sidestepping into this system? Or any other alternative control methods that I might be able to try out?
What exactly do you mean? Are you talking about what the right stick does in a standard console FPS? A lot of recent third person console games use those controls, but move the camera back, so you actually see your character. The success of Resident Evil 4 and Gears of War made this popular. Having the right stick rotate the camera has been done since the early days of the PlayStation 2. Most older games just had the character face the way they were moving. A ton of games still do it, like the God of War series and Prince of Persia, but games that focus on ranged weapons seem to have abandoned that.
Before dual analog, Turok for the N64 used the only stick the controller had to do what right analog sticks tend to do most of the time these days. But you had to use it with your left thumb, and use digital movement with four buttons. I think this is more likely what you mean.
Or, are you talking about having the character face the direction you are pointing? In that case, using a trigger on top of that is pointless, considering the thumbstick is already analog.
My idea is that it’s probably not worth doing. You have an analog system for looking, and speed. You could add a bunch of buttons to point movement, but that’s going to feel broken and clumsy compared to an analog stick, and considering you’re already incorporating a gamepad, why not use dual analog?
Tell us more about your game and what you don’t like about the “standard” way of controlling that type of game. Also, tell us what input methods you’re requiring. Obviously an analog stick and an analog trigger is required. So you’ve moved beyond what everyone has connected.
I am talking about having the character look towards the direction the thumbstick indicates, but the thumbstick does not make the character move. Pressing the trigger makes the character move in the direction they are facing. I don’t want to use any other input to control movement.
I realise it is conventional to have one stick to control looking and one for movement, but I’d like to experiment with a setup like the one I described.
Although I find dual analog very easy to use, I notice that a lot of people who have just started playing games find it confusing. I also hoped that freeing up the other analog might give me some ideas about different uses for it.
There’s nothing about the game that makes it unusual, at the moment it’s little more than a sandbox for testing these ideas. Third person viewpoint, camera currently rotates to follow where the character is looking. I am going to test having the character’s head and torso move with the gaze, then have their body turn when they actually start moving forward or try to look too far around - a bit like the way a real person might look and move around. I don’t really find myself strafing around too often! (that said, I’d still like sidestepping to be possible)
I liked this idea because I thought it might make a character’s movement look more natural, as well as giving a different feel to controlling the character. Just because a lot of games use the conventional two-stick method you described doesn’t mean I should give up on this idea!
I don’t think it’s fair to criticise the fact that I am using an analog game controller just because not everyone has one connected. At this stage, I am just testing ideas. If something works, I will see if it can be adapted to other means of inputs.
That’s not enough information. Does “look towards” refer to “FPS look”, or “Mario 64” look? That is, if you press down, do you look down, or do you turn around?
I played games for about 16 years before trying dual analog (Halo), and I was absolutely horrible with it for several hours. I didn’t find the concept of it confusing, but I definitely needed practice to get comfortable with it. You’re moving around in a 3D video game world, with a thing you hold in your hand. It’s going to take some getting used to, if you want to have freedom.
Good. Strafing and backwards running look ridiculous in every video game. People don’t do it!
I didn’t criticize it. I hate mouse and keyboard control! Maybe you can make something that changes my mind.
Hmm, I think this sounds interesting. I’m one of those people who sometimes find dual analog controls tricky and my target audience tends to be people who definitely find it tricky most of the time.
What would be most interesting is if you could post some of your experiments as web players to let people try them out and discuss how they find them. I can see that this would be a problem if you need to have a playstation analog controller so it may be best if you can make the tests for keyboard/mouse.
I also agree with Jessy that it really does depend on what kind of game you’re making. I can see the system you’re proposing working well for exploration games where you have to look around a lot but not move while you’re doing it. For more movement based games, you could try the opposite system. So the controller the controller lets you move unless you press the “look” button when it switches to move your gaze. However, for FPS type games where people want to look and move in different directions at the same time the dual analog approach is probably the best way.
How about a “fox and hound” pathfinding approach? Basically, you create an object of interest your character will seek out on its own while you move it around the level. (Or maybe a simple “point and click” approach using a grid of trigger points…)
Ah, gotcha. Pressing down (or up, if you’re invert-y inclined) will make you look down. Turning around would be accomplished by looking 180 to the left/right.
Good. Strafing and backwards running look ridiculous in every video game. People don’t do it![/quote]
Except in rare cases… so I was trying to work out the most intuitive way to add it to my control setup.
I didn’t criticize it. I hate mouse and keyboard control! Maybe you can make something that changes my mind. [/quote]
I like the analog controls mainly for the thumbstick and trigger - the actual analog parts. Prevents you from having to implement a ‘hold shift to run’ type control.
The mouse alone could handle this setup, with a little tweaking and sensitivity/threshold adjustments, with the mouse acting as the thumbstick and the mouse wheel acting as the trigger - roll wheel forward slightly to walk, or a lot to run. Roll it back to stop.
I haven’t tried this, mind you, it sounds a bit awkward… but maybe it would become easy like dual analogs.
That’s not a bad breakdown Harissa. This will be mainly exploration over action. I already have an idea about handling combat and anything where a fast reaction is required.
I was just discussing this with my friend, and he mentioned that he loved the controls for the jeep (is it called a Warthog?) in Halo. I realised it’s pretty much the same as he described, only using the trigger for accelerate instead of the second thumbstick… seems to work in Halo, and I think with a smaller character there wouldn’t be any issues with turning circles.
I think either of these would disconnect the player from the character, as they are more indirect control methods, so they are probably not the right idea for this game.
The fox and hound idea is interesting though - I wonder what kind of games it would work best with. It would probably allow you to have some interesting use of the camera - the player doesn’t have to worry about complex navigation, so you can place the camera in ways that would normally obstruct or provide limited views.
That doesn’t mean anything from a control standpoint. Unless you’re wearing a headset of some type, a game doesn’t respond to you actually looking around.
However, given this…
I assume you mean “tilt the stick left or right until the camera has rotated 180”. If so, that’s “console FPS camera control”. Are you always looking at the character’s back?
Penny Arcade Adventures on the Mac/PC and the DS Zelda game used this. It’s a great control scheme, but there was no camera control whatsoever.
This is the way all vehicle games control. But they don’t strafe. And I don’t see how you could possibly drive that thing without constantly adjusting the camera with the right stick.
There are countless combinations of things you can do with control schemes. You need to figure out what you actually want the player to be able to do. If you want maximum freedom with one hand, use this.
My bad - I did mean tilt until the camera has rotated 180. You are always looking at the character’s back at this stage, yep.
I’m not sure if it is, I remember being surprised about the vehicle’s control in Halo when I first played it. Most vehicle controls only use the X-axis/left-right of a controller, but this example uses the full range.
Hah, that would really be making the game accessible to everyone.