Ashes Of Creation MMORPG

Has anyone seen this Kickstarter campaign?
Thoughts?
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1791529601/ashes-of-creation-new-mmorpg-by-intrepid-studios

Looks like another game made by a group of former AAA developers who will probably make a bundle on Kickstarter. I see a few cool special stuff, but too bad they stuck with the archetypes of all fantasy games.

1 Like

With over $1 million in three days, they may set a record on Kickstarter. They must have had a crazy large following prior to launching to get that kind of money. Unless maybe a bunch of huge outlets covered it. I’m too busy to keep track of such things, so I suppose the project could be very well known even if I’ve just heard of it.

It is not hard for AAA developers to get that kind of money. It is the indies who people no longer trust.

1 Like

Is it made with Unity?

1 Like

1m is nothing for an MMO. Shovel Knight got 300k and it was peanuts for their mighty 6-man team.

Oldest news articles appear to be January with a Facebook page as far back as September. I’m going to chalk up their success more to the presence of highly active MMO news sources. People are constantly on the look out for new MMOs regardless of whether they offer a truly new experience or not.

My own experience with MMOs was with a gaming community that would regularly jump ship to a new one every few months with the goal of quickly leveling beyond the majority of the player base and dominating PvP. My favorite memory is of the Aion Kaisinel server where our defunct faction kept second place months after we left.

A million doesn’t seem like much for an MMO. That’s enough to keep a dozen or so people in work for a year. Is that all it take to do an MMO these days?

1 Like

With their contacts, they probably have a ton of investors as well. Kickstarter is more a way to build a community and get people invested so they play the game when it comes out.

6 Likes

Yeah, when I said over a million in three days was a lot, I meant relative to Kickstarter, not relative to the budget of MMO games. Their goal was less than a million, so I’m assuming they have funding outside of KS as well.

1 Like

Yep, Kickstarter is also being used as a way to give investors a way to gauge interest in a project lately, a practice I’m not totally in love with as it gives people a really warped perception of how much games cost to make.

7 Likes

Considering the world already has way more MMO’s than players to play them, this is truly amazing. And I definitely agree that $1M isn’t even close to enough money to make something good if the goal is to actually win players away from other games. Need probably 10 times that, before marketing.

UE 4

It’s hard to tell what they mean exactly, but apparently the game world is supposed to be very reactive/interactive compared to other MMOs. At least, that seems to be the unique selling point of this game.

Did you watch the Kickstarter video? That goes into more detail.

1 Like

I worked at Turbine in 2004 and proposed having a world that reacted in meaningful ways to player actions.
I didnt just say that vague sentence, I actually had real game mechanics written down to illustrate how to do it.
No MMO has really done this yet. They of course ignored me.

What these guys are saying is the high level stuff.
It really depends on what they can actually show as game mechanics.

4 Likes

Have you ever presented the idea to anyone else?

It’s a miracle they managed to create a game like DDO. It’s only recently that they managed to fix the bulk of the exploits (item duplication, experience potion reuse, etc). There are still plenty of broken mechanics and some of the ladders in some of the dungeons are still misbehaving (go to climb them and they reset you back down at the bottom).

Another generic mmo :roll_eyes:

1 Like

And that is the sad thing. They have the talent, the money, (I am convinced they probably have investors outside of kickstarter) and yet they make the same old sort of MMO that everyone else does.

1 Like

They stay on prooven grounds, mmo is risky because it involves lot of money and success is based on players keeping coming back to the game. They simply follow what has been made thousand of times in mmos.
Anyway it’s perhaps due to the genre and we should not expect something extraordinary from mmo side.