Can't parse 2nd JSON object, C#, litjson

I’m trying to parse in some data from a json file to create a list of objects in unity. The first object in the json array parses just fine, but the second one gives me an Argument is out of range error. I can’t figure out why this is happening.

JSON file:

[
  {
    "characterName": "name",
    "characterAvatar": "CharacterSprites/",
    "characterID": 0
   },
   {
    "characterName": "name2",
    "characterAvatar": "CharacterSprites/",
    "characterID": 2
   }
]
void Start() {
        characterData = JsonMapper.ToObject(File.ReadAllText(Application.dataPath + "/StreamingAssets/Character Database.json"));
        ConstructCharacterDatabase();

        if (characters.Count != 0) {
            print(characters[1].characterName);
        }
    }

    void ConstructCharacterDatabase() {
        for (int i = 0; i < characterData.Count; i++) {
            //characters.Add(new character(characterData[i]["characterName"].ToString(), characterData[i]["characterAvatar"].ToString(), (int)storyOrderData[i]["characterID"]));
            Debug.Log(characterData[i]["characterName"].ToString() + "  " + characterData[i]["characterAvatar"].ToString() + "  " + (int)storyOrderData[i]["characterID"]);
        }
    }

I’v commented out the line that adds new objects to my list. I write a debug.log line for testing. The first object in my json file is printed, on the second loop of the for loop it gives an error.

Should the ‘storyOrderData’ part not say ‘characterData’?

It would help that when you post code, you also let us know what line in the code you posted that the error appears on.