Clones of old games.. Legal standing?

Where does the industry stand on clones of old games? When I say old, I mean commodore 64 era or possibly Amiga. If a game is classed as abandonware, is it safe to clone and to what degree can it be similar?

Is the problem mainly due to trademarks and names rather than game content? Ie, can a near perfect clone be made if the name is different? abandonware seems a bit of a grey area to me.

I believe Taito is releasing Arkanoid on the iPhone and I’m guessing there are already many arkanoid/breakout clones already available.

Does anyone know of any good resources to help find out if a trademark exists or if an old games rights are still held by a publisher?

Edit:
I just read this on another thread…

“I believe there is an application live on the App Store that infringes my rights (e.g., trademark, copyright, name and likeness). How can I report this?
If you believe an application that is currently live on the App Store infringes your rights,
you will need to contact Apple’s legal team with specific information about the application and they can assist with further action.”

I wonder where this and abandonware stand with someone who has made a clone… Do they then have right of their clone over your clone…

Matt. :roll:

I guess that you can as long as the game is abandonware.

This is from Wikipedia:

I believe the concept is to find the legal owner of the brand/name/concept (if there is any) using various online tools like Trademarks | USPTO, http://www.marcaria.com or http://www.ptdla.org/trademark and get in touch with the legal owners.

I myself would not start a production without any permissions and contracts (call me paranoid, but i’ve been sitting in court too many times about copyright issues).

Other thing is, if you make it NON-profit hobby project of an old game. Especially if you make “look-alike” based on the same idea.

Founded URLs about this:
http://www.gamedev.net/community/forums/topic.asp?topic_id=544351

http://www.gameproducer.net/2006/05/03/legal-issues-with-remakes/

Found Google’s one, seems solid : Google Patents

@rouhee - those two links don’t give for happy reading.

It appears that games which publishers may have considered dead a few years ago are being reborn with the development of the mobile device, which are making them off limits to developers.

Hmmm, all this does seem very grey. There is a nice lunar lander type game currently on this forum; where would the developer stand if they decided on an iPhone release? (sorry to use your project as an example). Obviously the gfx etc are totally different to the 70’s original, as probably is the premise, but would the likes of Atari still side that the game mechanics are based enough on their old game, even with a name other than ‘lunar lander’

Matt.

Generally speaking, as long as you don’t make an exact clone with a title that might cause someone to confuse your game with the original, you probably aren’t going to get sued. As it is, there are now so many games which borrow elements from “old” games, truly original titles are becoming a rare find.

As for the developer end of the spectrum, you might find that some people will probably come to resent you for being a rip-off, especially if whatever you created doesn’t actually add anything innovative or beneficial to the experience. On the other hand, the gaming industry wouldn’t be anywhere near as big as it is now if game designers didn’t look at each other’s work every once in a while and ask “how can I make this even better?”

Warpack Grunts… Cannon Fodder…

Codemasters should have sued the pants off them :stuck_out_tongue: Obviously they didn’t because its difficult to say that a top-down war shooter is a totally unique idea :slight_smile:

I guess I’ll be coding ‘commando style’ from now on, at least that way, they never get my pants!

Would a hobby developer in his bedroom really get ‘hung out to dry’ or would a nice polite letter from their legal department asking for app removal be about its limit.

I must admit, I think i’ll put my love of old retro games and making a remake to the back burner and just enjoy them in their native habitat (well, on the c64 emulator).

Cheers all,
Matt.

You can clone as long as it contains different characters and names.

I think lunar lander is probably safe. I worked on a console game where we had some retro-style minigames. The publisher legal department rejected some of them but cleared our lunar lander minigame. I imagine breakout is safe, too, since there seem to be endless versions of it.

But take it on a case-by-case basis, research the game in question and any history of lawsuits, patents, etc. and be clear what you mean by “clone” - copying the game mechanics, the look, using a similar name. Here’s an interesting article on Abuse, which was partly but not completely transferred to the public domain and someone apparently went too far (gives an idea how that kind of thing is handled on the App Store, too) - Indie Game Producer: Abuse abuse

I’m not a lawyer, but its pretty simple.

If someone wants to sue you, they can. That doesn’t mean they’ll win, or that it wont’ be thrown out for being frivolous, etc.

Utilizing known IP is illegal. Cloning it so its slightly different is “gray”.

Realistically, they have the right to protect their assets. The closer you make something to a 1 to 1 clone, the stronger their case is.

To my knowledge, you would have a hard time protecting a genre. Otherwise Capcom would have sued Midway for mortal kombat decades ago.

So I think the best method is, don’t steal IP directly. If you have new art, new music, new sound, new names (ie, you’ve “built” everything yourself, even if the underlying concept was totally stolen/borrowed) you’re on safe ground.

Just don’t make Tetris.

#1 advise: Hire a lawyer.

#2 advise - and this is not legal advise, IANAL:

You need to be aware of the various laws that come into play here.

Copyright law protects a specific implementation only. Drawing a cartoon with a mouse can not be copyrighted. Mickey Mouse can. “RTS sci-fi game” can not be copyrighted. StarCraft can. In general, a reimplementation of something will usually be free of copyright claims. Of course, in the event of a lawsuit, you might have to prove that. Which is where it gets tricky.

Trademark law is more troublesome. Here, something that looks alike to something that’s a trademark will be found in violation, even if it was your original idea and done without any knowledge of the trademarked thing.

Patent law is even uglier. Fortunately, you’ll not likely run into it when you write a game.

So, clones are generally good as long as they’re not too close. You can not copyright a general gameplay idea. That’s why there are so many PacMan, Breakout, Lander, Pong, etc. clones out there.

You should not use the original’s name, artwork, etc. without permission. That would be a copyright and/or trademark violation.

No computer game is public domain at this time, unless it was specifically released into the public domain, since the terms are simply too long. As a guideline, you can always use Mickey Mouse. Anything older than Mickey is public domain. Anything younger isn’t. Disney will buy/bribe/lobby a new copyright extension when the time comes, so I figure this is a safe guideline for the time being. :slight_smile:

You might want to look up a talk that Jason Rubin’s(of Naughty Dog) father did at GDC a couple years ago. He is a lawyer and talks exactly about this subject.