First, let me preface this by saying that I don’t have much experience with game engines. I’m mainly limited to some Unreal modding I contributed to quite a few years ago.
I’ve read about Unity being great for prototyping games or for development of web games and iphone games.
What I was wondering was, what are the differences between something like Unity and Torque, as opposed to something like CryEngine or UE3?
Of course I know that CryEngine and UE3 are faster. I would ASSUME that it’s because they code to specific hardware, but I’m not sure. And I also assume that they have some extra neato bells and whistles. But those engines cost upwards of several thousand dollars + royalties.
Unity and Torque are a tiny tiny tiny piece of a bitty fragment of those when it comes to cost. Why the HUGE disparity?
Also, with PCs getting more and more powerful, by 2012, could I expect that version of Unity to be able to give me XBOX 360 quality graphics and effects? Will I be able to make something like Gears of War?
Also, with this version of Unity, would I be able to make something like the original Halo?
Hypothetically of course. I’m not going to be making Halo - Winning Guy edition any time soon.
Now Unreal is a great engine if you’re looking to support the latest and greatest.
There actually is a downside (beyond cost) for independent developers of those big name engines: difficulty! They are not meant to be easy for 1-2 man teams. They are meant to be powerful. Check out some smaller dev teams what they’ve done with those engines and sometimes the results are horrid because you still need amazing artists that know the ins and outs to make the game look good.
But having said that, what you’re really paying for (in my guess) is a proven tech. In the business world this is worth gold. If you’re in a company with money and they want to know what tech you’re going with, everyone has heard of CryEngine and Unreal Tech. Also, they probably have nice available support.
I think UNITY has very good price, user friendly interface and runs pretty solid.
Unreal Engine may be amazing however, your probably going to need a big team like Timmer said.
UNITY can make some commercial quality games! If you got the right skills and a dedicated team then UNITY is the way to go. Don’t bother trying to get higher-end engines. Make a few games (5 to 8 ) and once you think your ready you can try save up your earnings for more diverse engines.
I’m probably going to stick to UNITY for a good 8 years. Make some good quality games with my team and we might earn attention from the gaming world. It could make us obtain a job with a great company.
Conclusion:
UNITY: User friendly and has a good number of features (Multi platforming, etc.)
Unreal: SUPER Non-User friendly, has lots of revolutionary features and is garunteed to make a commercial quality game (If your a pro).
Unity’s graphics engine is quite last gen. You won’t reach good realism with it. All it is good is for stylized games. And they want you to get pro to get some additional shaders. How sad.
I’ve not developed with CryEngine or UE3, but a lot of it has to do with target market and level of support. It’s a market that is always pushing the bleeding edge and dealing with fairly rigid deadlines. It’s important to have that direct line of support with the engineers of your engine.
That’s really artist dependent. I’ve never felt that Unity was holding me back.
Unity is a great game engine for what it’s worth (aka peanuts compared to Unreal/CryEngine). Unity Pro has things like realtime shadows and post effects (these are responsible for the modern effects in triple A games such as bloom, motion blur and other neat effects that can be expanded and rewritten since these effects use the shader system in Unity).
Unity Indie alone has access to built in shaders such as luminance, lightmapped and bumped (the bumped specular shader is sometimes called the UE3 shader…use it and you’ll know why ). And you can make your own shaders right within the engine if you want.
The look of your game will be dependent on the art you’ll import into it and what shaders and effects you’ll use. Unity hasn’t stopped me in that regard. You want to make something that looks like Halo:CE? If you have the right artists, you could make something that looks like Halo 3 (or even better!) with Unity right now.
Regarding performance, if you don’t do basic optimizations, your game will suffer. You can do incredible optimizations and have really awesome effects at the same time.
Have a look around the showcase forums. You’ll find a couple of games with good triple A quality art.
But graphics aren’t everything. Make sure you’re game plays well too! Good luck with whatever it is you’ll do!
Please don’t go about saying things on our behalf (especially when they’re inaccurate like the above), thanks.
We offer Indie as an incredibly cheap entry point into our tool, for only $199 you get the vast majority of our engine’s functionality with a few limitations, custom shaders is not one of those limitations (some “fancy” shaders use things like render texture and other Pro-only abilities but you can definitely write custom shaders in Indie). Then on top of that, for only $1500 we offer Unity Pro, and I say “only” as that really is a great price for the toolset being offered. It’s up to you, do you want to make really great games? If the answer is yes then start with Unity Indie and you can upgrade if/when necessary to gain access to the Pro features.
But again, custom shaders are supported in both Indie and Pro. The reasons for Pro upgrades go beyond “us wanting you to get Pro to get extra shaders”, it’s about some graphical abilities, things like streaming video textures, plugins and more. Johan misses the bigger picture with that (too) brief and inaccurate statement. If you want to see the full feature breakdown based on which license you buy then take a look at the License Comparison page.
I wouldn’t be so sure about that; it depends on what you’re doing. With those engines you can push things harder, not least because you have the source code, which you don’t get with Unity (unless you buy a source code license, which isn’t cheap either). But for more casual games, there isn’t going to be a noticeable speed difference. Also, a fair amount of gameplay is scripted in UnrealScript, which seems to be quite a bit slower than the scripting in Unity.
The majority of a game’s art quality is related to the number and skill of the artists involved, and if you have an AAA team of dozens of artists, the cost of the engine isn’t going to be your major problem anyway.
The main reason I ask is because I am an artist myself. So of course I’d like to see how much I could push the engine.
For example, if I were to create a super high quality normal map in Zbrush and put it on a 10,000-15,000 polygon mesh, could I expect it to look at least similar to what we see in Gears?
At this moment in time, I’m not even really thinking about it in a real time game. I’m just curious as an artist.
Personally, I think Unity owns the Gambryo (Oblivion) engine. The island demo looks better than anything in Oblivion and I lose immersivity by everything building in front of my eyes even with a good computer and high settings.
I know the CryEngine was mentioned and not Gambryo, but I thought I would compare with a “commercial” engine out there.
I bought Unity Pro for the fantastic water. Water is very important to me and Unity has about the best water I’ve seen in an indie game. Look at the sewers demo also if you want to see what I mean.
Well, I suppose you could download the demo and do the following:
1). Import your 10,000+ polygon model into Unity as well as the texture and normal maps.
2). Create a material in Unity for your model and assign the material the built in bumped specular shader.
3). Drag your model into the scene and assign the material to the mesh object.
This is of course a very rough step process to do it. You would have to be a bit familiar with the engine to know what to really do. But if the steps worked for you, then you are now the proud owner of a common Unreal Engine 3 model right in Unity.
if the object in question is a woman or girl - then there maybe will be some market i guess. Just google for Virtual Girlfriend, iGirl etc…
Even my first Unity iPhone project is nothing more than a virtual dancing 3d girl ( was not my idea - just for learning). But of course i do not know how well and if at all this will sell …