So I’m having the strangest bug occurring while using Unity 5.6 dropdowns. Before I go any further, let me just state that I have tried reproducing this in a new project but have not managed to do so. I post this here in the hopes that someone might have seen something similar and that we can maybe together come up with a repro case so we can file a proper bug report.
Background
In short, I have panels that contain among other things dropdown boxes. There are several layers of hierarchy and I also use both vertical layout groups and horizontal layout groups at different levels of the hierarchy, with a content size fitter at the top level. The panels are displayed in screen space but are positioned each frame to correspond to a world space position. This is to achieve a ui component that follows an object in world space but does not rescale or anything. When the user wants to edit data, the panel stops following the object and becomes draggable.
Problem
When the user starts editing and wants to select a different item in a dropdown box sometimes the panel containing the items is, for some reason, displayed in world space instead of screen space. This seems to depend on things like distance to the camera and orientation of camera but I can’t say for sure as I can’t come up with a case where it happens with 100% certainty.
Inspection of editor view shows that the items of the dropdown are positioned correctly in relation to their parent, they are only displayed in world space (so shader issue maybe?).
Pics or it didn’t happen Game view: In this image you can see the items of the dropdown positioned in world space.
Editor view: In this image you can see that the items are located correclt in the editor view. They are then transformed somehow in the game view to appear to be in world space. Inspection of the transform also indicates that the gameobject actually is positioned correctly, just somehow displayed in the wrong position.
For now I have downgraded to Unity 5.5.3 and that seems to work. As this seems like a fringe case I’m afraid that it will be hard for QA to pin down unless given a repro case so for the love of Odin, Thor and all that you may find holy, please if you have encountered anything similar, please sound off below! Otherwise I fear I’ll be stuck in the nether with 5.5.3 for all time to come…
I haven’t experienced your exact bug, but after upgrading a project to 5.6 my dropdowns are now blocking all input and not showing the content that should be inside while also preventing the user from selecting an option or closing the dropdown. My experience may be tied to world space rendering but it’s hard to be sure without burning more time.
If I add a new dropdown and try to rebuild it the same thing happens. At this point I believe the dropdowns are broken, I never had an issue using them in the past.
My current plan is to revert back to 5.5 until this is fixed. What happened to the stable releases that have been a big speaking point recently, this is game/flow breaking if a user opens one of these…
We had a problem similar to TurnOnTheGames issue. However, we did find a work around yesterday.
In the Dropdown>Template, change the system from Clamped to Elastic. We found that the issue is the same as having an auto content size fitter on a scrollable system. The position and size values would become NaN.
Once we found that the panel had the same NaN results we tried elastic and boom. We had a work around.
I’ve just updated my Unity to the actual version. Still I’m facing this error:
“my dropdowns are now blocking all input and not showing the content that should be inside while also preventing the user from selecting an option or closing the dropdown. At this point I believe the dropdowns are broken, I never had an issue using them in the past.”
Karl, when will you release a patch for this? It is very frustrating! Thanks!
I’ve just updated to 5.6.0p3. Still, my dropdown doesn’t work. It’s very confusing. I click on it, it shows the options, but then I cannot select one, and sometimes I can’t even close it anymore. Do you have any pieces of advice maybe?
