Galaxy Tab 10.1 vs Xoom vs Transformer

Hi guys,
I’m gonna buy one of these :wink:
Just wanted to hear your thought on them, so please mention if you already own one of them :slight_smile:

I’m setting my sights on Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 but the fact is I don’t trust Samsung that much (proven over time actually!)

I see that xoom and 10.1 are pretty much the same except that 10.1 has a better camera rec (1080) and on the other hand xoom is HDMI ready with no converter! :wink:

They are powered by the same processor so I’m willing to hear your thoughts :slight_smile:

Thanks in advance

I would go for the transformer if what you said about Samsung is true. I heard Xoom is a bit over priced and samsung apparently is the king of android market now. Lots of androids are made by Samsung. But i think Asus would be more stable. Transformer looks pretty solid too. :smile:

I have a Xoom as a test device and I do not recommend it. The specs sound good on paper, but it’s sluggish in actual use, and the display quality is inexcusably bad. Color accuracy is simply terrible, and any kind of motion on screen leaves a very nasty “ghosting” behind the moving object in question, an effect that is more pronounced if the pixels in question are darker or black.

Thanks guys!
So, I’m scratching the Xoom from the list for now!

@MikaMobile,
So you say that the refresh rate of the screen is at terrible rate, well, that’s not good to hear, because some of those tablets are gonna be our customer somehow, damn Motorola :frowning:

There are a lot of choices coming out everyday, so it is getting harder and harder to choose!
Is there any other tablet that you guys have had any experience with?

I’m specially curious about 10.1 since it looks so nice as well :wink:

Ghosting is not caused by the refresh rate (which is nearly always 60 anyway) but by the screens reaction time. Anything beyond 8ms and you get ghosting on fast things, especially if their “to black” reaction time is bad as thats the worst case of ghosting (color on black is just sooo visible)

And no not really hard aside of LG where its a bid of case to case (avoid the 3D and you are fine normally): If Samsung or HTC is written on it, its fine. If Motorola is written on it, you deserve any punishment for buying it, but happily the device will take care of that already as Android 3.0 and 3.1 on the xoom have shown very well (might sound hard but they like RIM just missed the whole trend for too many years and lack that far on the required experience and knowhow that they just better would vanish for the customers sake)

HTC at the time just has no Android 3 tablet (flyer is Android 2.4 wich a seriously overclocked Snapdragon 2 in it that really makes the competition fear it. To kill something like a Xoom it does not even need to go all out) likely cause they are not willing to not use HTC Sense and with the deep modifications (and resulting also long time to update to new android versions) they might just not get Android 3 certified at all for the time being.

Any but those 4 brands is to be avoided anyway out of my view, cause they don’t represent anything “major” which normally goes hand in hand with not enough qualified staff to maintain the hardware and platform, often that then are cheapo asian stuff (huwai for example) or in case of Arcos just something you should generally avoid if the target was android gaming and development of games. (they didn’t get market certified for a long time by google, for really good reasons!)

Thanks dreamora!
I’m getting more confident to go for Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 although I’m still afraid!

Anything else people? :smile:

I have all 3 for developement. The Galaxy Tab has the best screen of them all. Besides that I haven’t noticed much difference between the devices.

The Touchwiz (optional) update for the Tab just came out. I haven’t downloaded it yet but you can read about it here http://www.anandtech.com/show/4582/samsung-touchwiz-ux-review-honeycomb-gets-skinned

Since there is only 1 chipset and 1 speed in all of these tablets so performance just isn’t that different.

The good thing about the Xoom is that you know you will get OS updates the fastest if that is something you care about.

If money doesn’t matter get Tab cause screen is great, if it does get the Transformer.

I would suggest the Transformer for additional ports like USB 2.0, Micro SD, Mini HDMI.

You will not be able to get around the transformer for the time being.

Xoom at court, Galaxy Tab at court - good thats in europe where apple can’t lock them in court for many months to years just cause they have cash like stupid

ive tried all 3, i recommended the galaxy tab it just feels light weight and slim, but all 3 are basically the same… all perform the same in my opinion.

i just bought galaxy tab 10.1 n want to develop games in android environment. Is this device could be a standard device for testing our games?

I have asus t, it feels great and run smooth :slight_smile:
and i also want to enter the development area of android, just i hope that one day i will :slight_smile:

Asus Transformer has no landscape mode. Acer ICONIA A500 is also a good choice.