How to make 2D lighting look natural?

Hey everyone.
So I’m trying to make lights in my game, but every time I have more than 1 light in one place near each other, everything gets way too bright. Here are some screenshots of what I’m talking about.
Thanks!

51957-screenshot-3.png

51958-screenshot-2.png

51958-screenshot-2.png

Maybe you can reduce the brightness of the light and add some ambient light.