I wonder about criteria for asset store submissions acceptance .

Today my package Ancient Greece Vol 1 got declined with the following reply.

"
Unfortunately we don’t feel this submission is quite up to quality standards we hold on the Asset Store. As such, we have chosen not to publish this asset. However, we greatly appreciate the time and effort spent in preparing your submission.

A good deal of your textures aren’t up to the standard qualities that we try to uphold. All of your pivot points aren’t correctly set up and centered properly."

I am posting some stills for people to see the quality of textures and work also a video fly by of the general area. State if you like it , even more if you would buy it and comment on quality but before you do this take a look at a random asset that is online on the asset store which is considered of high quality.

See how these asset packs compare and tell me am I crazy that I am mad about having this product declined ?
Youtube video





Back in 2013 the asset store would accept pretty much anything, because there wasn’t all that much in the store. Now, with the asset store being very full, they’re becoming a lot more picky about what makes it in. They want to make sure all new assets cover the basics, like pivot points and so on, because customers complain about things like that, and have told Unity that they need to be more careful about the quality of the assets they let into the store.

The Asset Store standards have increased recently, you should strive to make your own assets better. This is driven not only by modern technology but also a lot of complaints about low quality stuff bloating the store.

The asset you posted was last updated in 2013, an unfair timeframe for comparison. Here is a more recent asset.

1 Like

Have you noticed the price tag on the one you are suggesting It’s 450 USD? I did not search for a passed submission just saw it at the environments in the store.

Yes, and it’s selling quite well. Think about that.

That’s like comparing a Mercedes Benz with a bicycle man and it’s not the point of what I am saying

But you did understand the point, right? There’s a lot of old stuff in the store that nobody wants to buy because it is of low quality. Unity is trying to raise the bar on quality, so that even inexpensive and free items added to the store are more worth the customer’s attention.

They gave you an idea of what you needed to fix in order to get your art submitted. You might try addressing those issues and resubmitting.

LaneFox pointed to an expensive item. Most of the things being approved for the store are not that expensive. There’s no need to focus on that.

1 Like

I literally just picked something randomly out of the Recent list. Here’s something cheaper and more aesthetically comparable.

I get the point but if Unity wants to have a “high quality” store then it should take off the store the “not of high quality” stuff and accept only high quality cause when they have low quality stuff on the store they can’t decline products that are not of so high standards as the $450 asset that LaneFox talked about

I will fix what they asked for and re submit , graphics wise I feel mine is as you said comparable to this

Unity can’t remove the old stuff, or at least they haven’t figured out a way to do it yet. It’s more complicated than it seems, because usually there’s at least one person out there who bought the item, and they expect it to remain available for download from the store.

Previously, nothing was ever removed from the store. Now - in the last year - with the permission of the vendors, Unity is marking some items as “deprecated.” But there’s still a lot of old stuff in the store that isn’t supported any more, the vendors are unresponsive, and customers keep complaining to Unity about it. But, as I said, it’s a complicated situation and you can’t just remove things.

I think they ought to automatically move everything that the vendor hasn’t updated in six months to a separate archive bin. That way people would know which items are no longer supported, as within six months they’d fall out of the regular store and into the archive. And if the item is audio or a simple art object, which maybe doesn’t need updating so frequently, the vendor can still show it is supported by updating a readme in the pack twice annually, thereby keeping it active.

3 Likes

Hmmm, if this is what Unity is going to accept from now on, it will be out of my price range and the range of what my game can handle. I don’t want super duper stuff that runs on very high quality. I want mid-ranged for my players who will have DX9 at the most and playing on laptops.

I hope this is just an extreme example.

I like these very much and would buy them, depending on the price of course. Looks to me like Unity wanted you to fix the pivots and make sure they were centered and yeah, that is important when placing items.

I hope you resubmit. :slight_smile:

1 Like

Definitely fix the pivots, I think that could be a key point, hopefully you will be accepted after that.

Regarding textures, I don’t know if this is the issue but there are a couple of points you could improve (though I like your stuff in general).

At point 1 there is a clear seam - you might want to match up the brick work?

At point 2 - the lighting appears incorrect with shadow on top on the bricks rather than below in the area one might expect to be occluded. Not sure if this is baked in to the diffuse or an incorrect normal?

Also, are your using a PBR / Standard shader setup? The guys on the asset store are quite keen that new assets follow a PBR workflow I think. At least for realistic / semi realistic stuff.

1 Like

Thank you Teila, not every Indie out there can spend over 100 for one thing in the asset store, this asset was going to be sold for 45

Thank you for the note Singularity, this is a still image in you watch the video on you tube you will get the idea and feel of this asset
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ofYUvtyoqk