Hello, I made this thread to find out if Unity is right for me. I have 2 ideas for games and I was wondering if these are good to make in Unity or if I should go to CryEngine or something else?
A third person shooter with good graphics, a few cutscenes, and it would be campaign.
A multiplayer cops vs robbers fps with mid size maps and decent graphics.
If any questions, ask below, thanks!
Firstly a Multiplayer FPS is a HUGE endeavour in any game engine. Not for the faint of heart. A good budget, and a team would really help. Depending on the size of your budget and team, I think on average your looking at a year of work to make a decent MP FPS. A single player first person campaign is easiest in Unity. The reason being, for third person or multiplayer, you need character animations of all character actions, idle, run, reload, crouch, ect⌠If your a good animator then it would be easier, or, you could also purchase animations from a site like Mixamo, but it would be expensive. For a first person single player, you only need the arm/hand animations that the player seeâs, and a couple basic âbad guyâ animations. There are a couple free resources I came across that will make this a lot easier. Firstly I like Dastardly bananaâs Fps constructor, itâs a little old, but still usable, It sets you up with hand/arm animations, firing/raycast, weapon switching, explosions, health, ammo counter, and a money/purchase system right out of the box. You can just swap out your own art assets guns ectâŚ
Check out this post for help to get it working.Animation keypress problem - Unity Engine - Unity Discussions
I think the leading resource for this type of game however, is âFps controlâ youâll find a link in the other link. I Think this would be your best bet. P.S. Some of the plugins, like âweapon controlâ cost money.
Wow Thanks! 
Your big reason to choose unity over other options is the asset store and multi-platform support. What is your experience? If youâre good at programming, give unity free a shot. If youâre good at having well defined ideas and making flows of actions, check out a few videos on playmaker.
Unity also has shiny things to tempt with. Check out the news for unity 5 on webgl and pbr shaders.
I have no experience with programming at all so I would buy Sam Teaches Unity to learn
Iâd recommend checking out Unityâs free learning resources before you invest money in other sources.
I mentioned playmaker because itâs visual programming, with support for custom actions when you want to modify or make your own custom âcode blocksâ to fit in to the visual coding puzzle.
It can even be used as a learning tool, since you can view the code being run by each code block provided with playmaker.
Learning to program is also a good idea 
So, I just wanted to add a word about FPS Control, Iâm currently working on a 2d game, but I have done some fps game design in the past. I downloaded FPS Control out of curiosity. The last time I used it, it was fine, but now, on the website it says âFPS Control is not yet fully compatible with The current version of Unityâ. I have version 4.5.5f1 of Unity, and it was a mess when I opened a level. I had to delete (saved them elsewhere), several scripts( all ProGrid), and the UnityEngine.dll to get it working. And also you have to add a lot of game objects into the inspector, which is quite confusing. I assume there working to update this but just be warned. That being said, it is a wealth of resources if you can get it working. I think the big lesson to be learned is âbeware of the Unity updateâ. You can lose all your work just by updating. Make sure you always backup your work on an external hard drive or on the âcloudâ. And once you start a project, only update if the update gives you something essential for your game, until you are done.
Screenie of the Shellshock demo level in FPSContol.
Just as a simple anwser, Should I use Unity for making my games or should I use something else?
Yes.
Unity is a very good free option, so you might as well give it a try.
