max to unity to maya?

Let’s just say I buy a MAX file. Now, Unity supports Max files, but how to do the animations of the model?

Can I use that “export mesh to Obj” to export the file as OBJ and then import to Maya or is that exporter not good enough for complex models? I also read that Unity is working on a really awesome new animation editor… now my question is this: Will the new editor be good enough to do complete animations or will they once again say: “This is good enough for basic animations but for advanced animations it would be best to use a dedicated modeling tool” or something similar?

Basically, i know an external modeling app will always be better than a feature built into Unity and I know the OBJ script exists, but what I would really like to know is how do Mac users make use of Max files with anything other than the default, built in animations (if any) that might be inside the Max file when you buy it?

Even Dexsoft who offers his models for sale on this very forum, even he has models that looks great, comes in multiple formats… and has no maya or fbx versions… So I have to buy the kit, buy windows, install parallels, run windows, buy max, install max, run max, load the model, export to collada, save to Mac drive, close max, shut down windows, close Parallels, open maya, import collada file, fix any glitches, save as maya file ready to animate for Unity…

Is that really the only way of making a Max file viable for Maya users on Macs?

Wow that’s complicated. Assuming the character is rigged and animated already I see a couple of options:

  1. Find a new character in a Maya format
  2. Export FBX animation from Max and retarget it onto your newly rigged Maya character.
  3. Export an FBX with model from Max and open it up in Maya for animation (you’ll need to build some rigging).
  4. Export the model from Max as an OBJ (which will have NO bones or skin weighting but will maintain quads and UVs) and import it into Maya for rigging and animation.
  5. Buy a PC
  6. Install windows on your Mac

If the character is just a model with a texture just export it from Max as an OBJ and import it into Maya.

I won’t speculate (much) on Unity’s animation tools but I suspect they’ll be more for movers (elevators, doors, bouncing balls) and not facilitate skinning, deformation or character animation. I wouldn’t want to animate a character in a game engine.

Hia

I read the animation system will allow for animation graphs but have extra features. I am assuming it will support rotation and transform keying as a minimum, but what with them already having a ragdoll generator, I was hoping then woudld create an updated version with built in rigging and IK. if they could do that then WOW!

At the moment I have Maya and MotionBuilder and neither support Max. When I read that Unity nows supports Max I got real excited as I have already seen tonnnnnes of awesome Max content but then I realized that Unity SUPPORTS Max files… i.e. as an alternate file format… nowhere die unity claim that they now FEATURE file conversions… huge difference… So it turned out that the Max support helps me exactly 0% since I don’t have Max. Well, I do, actually… I have Max 3.0. I haven’t owned a PC for 7 years now so no Max for me…

My only options apparent, is:

  1. Use my savings for Pro to buy Max
  2. Pirate Max
  3. Continue to ignore the Max file format
  4. Hope the animation tools are completely awesome
  5. For someone to tell me: “Yeh, at this link you can find a Mac app that converts Max to [format bla]”

i wanted to use this as an example http://www.dexsoft-games.com/models/villager_female.html but I just noticed it says:

so I can’t use this as an example any more as it DOES have FBX. Seems I owe an apology to Dexsoft for using him as an example… (My bad), but there are a lot of places that sell models and only offer Max. So often have I wantes something then just closed the tab because it was Max only… :frowning:

So, in answer to your options:

  1. Find a new character in a Maya format
    This is usually my best recourse apart from building it myself and taking a month to do so…

  2. Export FBX animation from Max and retarget it onto your newly rigged Maya character.
    for this I need Max…

  3. Export an FBX with model from Max and open it up in Maya for animation (you’ll need to build some rigging).
    For this I need max…

  4. Export the model from Max as an OBJ (which will have NO bones or skin weighting but will maintain quads and UVs) and import it into Maya for rigging and animation.
    For this i need Max…

  5. Buy a PC
    There is this lovable dead terrorist named Aghmed. To quote him in his most famous of sayings:
    “I kill you!”
    (p.s. if you don’t know Aghmed teh dead terrorist, google for Jeff Dunhamm)

  6. Install windows on your Mac
    Did that. Now I can use Windows software that “Covert Max to [format bla]”

I don’t understand something…

If you simply want to send date from 3dsmax to Maya you HAVE to use the FBX exporter.

FBX is developped by Autodesk to improve connection between idfferent Autodesk plateform…

Then if you have anyproblem with . you have to go on the Autodesk forumis the right area asking help if the FBX doesn’t export correctly your data from 3dsmac to Maya.

http://area.autodesk.com/forum/autodesk-maya/

Now buying 3dsmax for resolving the problem you will have better to pay a 3d artist for this job :lol:

And forget the obj plugin, this is a very bad one -__-…

you can also try Collada…

Make no mistake, I am NOT a fan of the OBJ format. It always gives me grief.

My question is simply this:
How do Mac users convert Max files to FBX ?

oh yeah doesn’t have FBX for 3dsmax MAC, only for Maya MAC :lol:

http://area.autodesk.com/forum/autodesk-fbx/fbx-plug-ins-import-export-discussions/important-new-point-release-fbx-20102/

I didn’t check it but on this url there is a line about

  • Autodesk FBX 2010.2 Converter (WIN / MAC / Linux)

If really you can’t find a PC with 3dsmax, send to me a MP with your file and I will do that… but try to ask on the autodesk forum too, there is probably a way for resolving your problem…

Also try to contact directly the “email us” link on this page :

They are very cool and will answer you in good short delay.

Jsut ask about a release of FBX plugins for 3dsmax MAC

3DS Max Mac?

I’m going to have to disagree about OBJ. The OBJ format is one of the cleanest and most “to the point” 3D file format available for the exchange of polygonal geometry between applications. This is why it’s used exclusively by many 3D applications like Zbrush and Xnormal. Sure, it’s limited to polygonal geo only but it handles quads, smoothing groups, UVs WITHOUT all the bloat.