Poll: FPS Games with or without weapons visible

Hello everybody!

I am seeking opinions about First Person Shooter perspectives. Is it important that this play perspective display the Hands and or Weapons on screen?

Do you like to see the gun shoot or sword swing? Or do you prefer your screen hands and weapons free?

Absolute, this is 2016-17 … Weapons Visible are a must?
or
Weapons Not Visible is OK, a simple cross hair will do fine.

What the heck FPSes have you been playing that don’t have visible weapons?

6 Likes

Just make it an option in the settings menu. :stuck_out_tongue:

  • Weapon must be visible.
  • Crosshair must be present, and must be customizeable (user should be bale to select shape and hide crosshair if they want to).
  • Character must have visible legs/body, and they should cast shadows.
6 Likes

Same as neginfinity.

Hey Murgilod! Yes I know crazy … what FPS has no weapons??? Well apparently some Might and Magic Games did this. I am working with a developer who loves this old school no weapon approach. I am trying to convince him that NO weapon means Project FAIL. I want a weapon and hands visible he does not. So I am trying to accrue evidence that supports my theory that people WANT weapons visible. And further people will NOT but a FPS game that does NOT have weapons visible. So yeah I agree with you crazy NOT to have them.

Might and Magic, Ultima Underworld and similar games aren’t fps. They are RPG dungeon crawlers.

Fps implies shooting, and a weapon. Of course, Quake 3 had settings for hiding weapon model (for performance reasons), but FPS means player has a gun.

There are couple of games that only display gun and not hands, though. (IIRC first painkiller did that). Not having hands is acceptable. Not having a gun is not.

2896283--213085--ken.jpg

1 Like

This video is an example of a non weapon FPS game. It said lets play might and magic 8. I just assumed that was their standard form of combat. Heroes of might and magic seems to have a strategy turn based combat system, yes. They must be 2 different games.

Thanks for the comments keep them and the votes coming! Thanks!

Well, we could also bring up Driller which also didn’t have a visible weaponl… but traditionally an fps game woudl have a gun model. The tradition started in times of Wolfenstein 3D.

Just because it worked in the past doesn’t mean it would fly today. It’s feedback, and we don’t live in an era where there are good technical excuses that can overturn the need for feedback.

2 Likes

The only (fps - type) games that (today) get away with no weapons on screen are rail shooters. Hmm - might be another reason never liked those that much.

Even good modern day (fps-like) dungeon crawlers have visible weapons - usually portrayed in melee slashes/hits or ranged weapons and magical missles.

Weapons perform several design functions.

  • They provide feedback on the weapon the player is using.
  • They indicate characteristics of that weapon (accuracy, range, reload rate).
  • They assist with aiming, humans are notoriously bad at picking the middle of the screen by eye.
  • They provide a static reference point on the screen. (Doing the same job your nose does).
2 Likes

The 21:0 vote paints a pretty clear picture that should convince even the most stubborn person. I have to wonder though, does it make sense for you two to work together when you can’t even agree on such basic things, and need to involve others for that? I don’t know all the facts, so don’t take this as “advice”, but sometimes cutting your losses is a good choice. Just something to consider.

4 Likes

hmmm i could see it for a mech lol
cause maybe the cockpit is in such a place the weapons arent visible, or maybe even the weapons are recessed into the chassis of the vehicle somewhat…

i woulda voted for something like “depends on design”

but a human character with guns… NOPE!!! gotta see the weapon!!
the feedback of visible weapon models adds ALOT to the enjoyment of the shooting

like ive been playing “Paladins” and the way one character reloads is just awesome lol
call of duty and stuff spend ALOOOTT ALOOT of attention to simply just how the gun models animate, simply for the excitement of how the gun moves, how the guys arms and hands move, like a magician maybe lol

the way she reloads, ALONE is really one of the biggest reasons i like that character… well, its like call of duty modern warfare 2’s FAL gun, it reloaded like that lol… 2:27

. actually, for like a Serious style shooter… i cant stand now… (since cod2 abouts)
when they dont have aim down sights … aka iron sights
and when they dont have LEAN and PRONE… its makes me say “F THIS TRASH 0/10”

RedOrchestra 2 is the best FPS … has leaning, has prone, has cover mechanics, has sprinting theres even “sprinting” of crouching and crawling and even has bayonet charge, die in like 2 -5 bullets max,
Medal of Honor Airborne had an AWESOME cover system, that seriously EVERY FPS should have…
(LOVE WW2 shooters… HATE modern shooters :stuck_out_tongue: )

System Shock 1 for DOS had Lean Forward !!!
FarCry 3 - NO LEAN , NO PRONE = TRASH!!! -1/10

Paladins gets away without that, cause its cartoony, and just a different style lol
… but like farcry, i wanna pretend iam a commando or something like that… without leaning and prone… HOW???
lol

… not saying you NEED those things, depends on design… i mean, those are my expectations of “realistic” FPS AAA games…

Thanks again for all the input Folks! I really Appreciate it. I am hoping to keep this post alive and get move votes from the community as a pool of 24 - 0 is clear. However it is not a very large data pool.

Keep the votes and input coming … I appreciate the effort!

If the numbers were close I would worry about a large data pool… but the hidden weapons number is still zero. :stuck_out_tongue:

This sounds like an argument a programmer would use when the evidence was clearly against them. LOL
Might consider strongly what @Martin_H suggested above.

3 Likes

The only FPS I’ve played that didn’t have a gun visible was Ghost Recon. I’m talking about the original released way back in the day, around 2001 or something. It was still fun, though I think I’d prefer to see the guns.