Queen Elizabeth Prize for Engineering: Create A Trophy Competition

As the developer of the browser based ‘QE Prize Trophy Designer’, I’d like to take this opportunity to announce this exciting and unique Unity built project that was commissioned by the Queen Elizabeth Prize Foundation.

Queen Elizabeth Prize for Engineering

The Queen Elizabeth Prize for Engineering , is a prestigious £1 million international prize awarded for ground-breaking innovation in engineering that has been of global benefit to humanity. The aim being to discover and celebrate stories of engineering success, raise the international public profile of engineering and inspire new generations of engineers to take up the challenges of the future.

The purpose of the Trophy Designer is to enable young people (16 to 24 yrs) in the UK to design the iconic trophy that will be presented to the winner of the QE Prize. The winner of the ‘Create A Trophy’ will receive a £5,000 prize with their trophy being 3D printed and according to this BAE article,

The Trophy Designer

The Trophy Designer is a simple, yet powerful, browser based 3D design tool, enabling users to easily construct complex forms from a small collection of ‘magnetic like’ primitives, where the only limit is your imagination.

The basic building blocks (primitives) are known as Platonic Solids, named for the ancient Greek Philosopher Plato. They have many interesting properties, but we use them for their aesthetic beauty and symmetry. In the designer they act as though they are magnetic, allowing you to stick them together or pull them apart.

Interaction is simple. After clicking on the boxes to empty out the platonic solids onto the worktop, you just click to pick up a shape and then click to place it, either on the turntable or to a previously placed shape. Once you have placed a few shapes you can click and drag on one to ‘detach’ it, and all the shapes attached to it. Now you can click to place this ‘chain’ of shapes, presenting a powerful means of cloning sections.

For more information visit the Queen Elizabeth Prize for Engineering website.

Link to the ‘Create A Trophy’ competition http://www.qeprize.org/trophy

Direct link to the Trophy Design Application http://create.qeprize.org (requires Unity plug-in obviously)

Link for an early version of the manual (limited proofing, just in case the final version is not on the website yet)

You can watch a ‘Quick Start’ video tutorial here

Building the Trophy Designer Using Unity

The Trophy Designer is built with Unity which proved itself to be a wonderful IDE to work with, enabling us to focus on prototyping, experimenting and tweaking, instead of all the other mundane tasks. Indeed with a short two month development schedule (including designing) it was paramount to ensuring the project was delivered on time and met expectations.

Unity’s low-level of access was vital in many aspects, such as being able to procedurally generate the platonic solids due to various requirements such as getting perfect alignment, writing specific shaders to achieve the shadows on a transparent plane etc.

Unity also proved very helpful with its numerous support functions for dealing with the necessary parenting, transforms, matrices and vector maths required. Again this allowed us to focus on the more important aspects of project. In fact Unity often made it trivial to add new features, the only reason in the end many weren’t was due to lack of time.

There was only one specific issue with Unity and that is parent/child relationships appear to be dealt with using recursion, meaning with a deep enough tree you can get an overflow error. So even though I wrote my own non-recursive methods, I was still left at the whim of Unity’s built in methods.

The only other issue I have was that I could easily have worked on this project for many more months as there are so many features and user support that could be added. Nearly everyone who uses the design tool will have some idea or feature they would like to see added and we have pages of such ideas. Unfortunately we just lacked the time to implement them.

Thanks

The QE Prize Trophy Designer gets Royal approval :wink:

Sadly I was unable to attend the “Celebration of Engineering” event at the The Royal Academy of Engineering, where The Duke of Edinburgh gave a speech for the naming of the Prince Philip House.

Neat project Noisecrime! Congratulations.
Gigi

Thanks Gigi, Its getting some good feedback and the number of entries for the competition is growing with some very unusual designs. We’d love to show off the designs we are getting but its a tricky situation since we don’t want to open it up to claims of one person copying another when there is a prize at stake.

Again its a problem with the deadlines, had we had an extra couple of months I would have proposed releasing a beta version, without the competition to enable a ‘gallery’ of user designs to be built in order to illustrate the possibilities and get some friendly ‘one-up-manship’ going before we started the actual £5k competition. Maybe if they run the competition again next year we’ll be able to do this.

The finalists have been selected (approx 38 seconds into the video). and the judging for the winner is taking place today (5th December).

Pretty impressed to see the variety and inventiveness of the designs submit. Just a shame we can’t show all the designs. I’ve seen the finalists trophy’s 3D printed and they look fantastic, hopefuly will be able to post some photo’s soon.

All the finalists work can be seen on the official QEPRize facebook page.

and the winner is … Jennifer Leggett.
Seen here holding her 3D printed winning design.

Rather nice blog entry on the announcement of the competition winner.

Very nice piece of UI work, I hope you can find some way to make it be useful beyond the scope of the competition.

Thanks, glad you liked it. Spent a good deal of time on the overall UI. As ever with these things it didn’t quite end up where I originally planned. Would have liked to avoid having any buttons/menu, but a short deadline meant changes had to be made.

It has proved to be very popular though, especially within the engineering field where i guess it got the most promotion. Having spoken with the client they are intended to keep the app up and they may want to expand it in the future, which would be exciting.

New video of the finalists 3D printed trophy and the judging. Its a great video, showcasing the 3D printed trophy’s, the finalists and capturing the joy and interest of the process.

Really love the fact that Unity enabled myself to write a cool little designer/modelling app that was capable of resulting in these wonderful 3d printed designs, they looks so cool.