[Starship troopers + Mech warrior] Can I get some feedback on this?

Community Showcases
1

I’m making this game that I want public opinions on
All my friends have lost their credibility

It’s basically starship troopers + mech warrior
It was main idea from the start

Literally any feedbacks are welcome at this point

2

Looks really good. You should definitely keep working on it. I’ve found that the “Work in Progress” forum has gone to crap lately. Very few replies seem to be given any more, whether positive or negative. You’re prob best off posting in a different forum for feedback. Good job though !

3

I agree, it looks awesome. I love the walking and movement feel - I feel like you need more visual feedback for your weapons - giving them some punch. Am I correct that this is intended to be a mobile game? The amount of On Screen ui, and the autotrigger settings makes me assume so - my final thought is that you could use some de-cluttering. move items off the screen when not in use, that sort of thing. Really, it looks like the game you have is very solid, it just needs some polish and punch up. Great job! I think you’d definitely get more responses and detailed feedback over at Polycount, Tigsource Forums, or at /r/gamedev/ on reddit.
Keep it up, and good luck!

4

looks awesome. only thing i would change is the ground texture to a bit more detail but all the rest looks good. keep it up

5

Really awesome! KEEP GOING!

6

I like how mostly everyone’s telling you to show this somewhere else to get feedback.

Also, the screen needs more GUI. It’s not completely covered as of yet.

7

If you post in other threads besides WIP and it is a wip - mods will move it to wip.
And I think it’s a good indicator of the quality of the game - if feedback isn’t offered from the wip forum - maybe the game isn’t interesting, maybe it won’t do very well when released. Although there are probably novel ideas incorporated in the latest flappy, runner, match 3, maze, puzzle, candy, gem, catch, ville, collect-a-thons.

I have to agree with AntMan - HUD/GUI is overwhelming. Try to think of creative ways to give feedback to the player visually without making a HUD elements or another button.

I like the locomotion of everything. The animation looks pretty solid. May consider some secondary things to move around, movement in the environment to add visual candy to the levels.

Keep it coming!