TreeCreator = deprecated feature, really Unity?

According to this post TreeCreator is a deprecated feature:

OK, so you guys plan to dump one of the best feature of Unity, probable in favor of SpeedTree. I have nothing against SpeedTree, but TreeCreator is a super powerful tool and you guys can make it even better, but seems you plan to abandon it, WHY? Seriously why you do that?

I’ve noticed in last few months, zero effort to fix TreeCreator bugs or add anything new. :frowning:

You guys have any solid reason to kill that feature? Anything else that forcing us to use SpeedTree?

5 Likes

Plus, Tree creator has that great thing about it that it is free, unlike SpeedTree. It’s like they’d say “We’re dropping Mecanim and Unity animation tools, but we’ll support Mixamo natively and you can do all animations in it and execute it using playMixamo(MixamoAnimation anim) call.”

1 Like

They’re too busy fixing just about everything else that broke in Unity 5.2. :stuck_out_tongue:

4 Likes

I really did worry about this at one point for a while. I don’t buy into (pun) the “software as a service” monthly subscription model.
Though allegorithmic’s monthly sub is such a fair deal and very worth it - I’m being tempted!

1 Like

Allegorithmic Live subscription is really fair, in the end you own a permanent license to use the tools. With Speedtree you own nothing. That’s the difference. I suspect the Speedtree for games license is very expensive, so that subscription was only way to let indies touch the product.

2 Likes

SpeedTree’s subscription was made to mimic the original Unreal 4 licensing. You’d have anything created with the tools but you wouldn’t have the tools themselves once the subscription lapsed. I would love to see more platforms take up the Allegorithmic licensing, but Unity has stubbornly stated it won’t happen.

Originally the license was to be perpetual and ~$500. They choose subscription likely to both increase the number of developers and to make more money at the same time.

It’s what, $20? You don’t need it all the time, you can just pay for one month when you need to create/modify trees and then cancel, Speedtree even suggested that’s what people do.

1 Like

I said, I have nothing against SpeedTree, ( well… expect some thing that are missing from tool, and I am not sure how receptive are SpeedTree devs at our requests). I am actually subscribed to SpeedTree, and I am doing exactly what you said, do your stuff, unsubscribe.

I just don’t understand why Unity don’t continue with TreeCreator, is super cool to can modify your tree INSIDE Unity editor, and modify different things, like leaf material color. In SpeedTree you have to do a new whole texture for that. Not counting that, since SpeedTree compiler is hidden into editor, I have not found a way to force trunk into atlas.

too bad , while tree Creator is a nice tool, it kinda sucks , particularly with the built-in vegetation system and built-in vegetation shaders… really.
i hope unity will leave the code for us to improve though.

1 Like

Open-sourcing the TreeCreator is definitely something we are considering.

9 Likes

that would definitely be something awesome, i already have a bunch of ideas to make it much better

I was about to remind them that if they asked super nicely this would probably happen :smile:

2 Likes

Ask nicely? What sort of place do you think this is? :wink:

5 Likes

A place where BoredMormon’s sole goal is to play the minigame of knocking me off top likes : >

4 Likes

Yup. Your onto me. Not far now. :slight_smile:

I have played with tree creator in the past when I was trying to build a procedural terrain generator. I wasn’t overly impressed with it. I can see the reason for dropping it once speedtree was intergrated. It hardly makes sense to maintain two different tree tools. Especially when trees are hardly a core feature of a game engine.

The subscription model is really no different from any of the other art tools out there. There is very little in terms of art editing built directly into Unity. And generally it doesn’t make sense to do so.

1 Like

When I release my game, I will become more powerful than you can possibly imagine.

2 Likes

Timeline? Just so I know when my last chance to beat you is. After I make the top I will have to find something else equally productive to invest my time in. Perhaps playing your game.

1 Like

Ages. You’ll have knocked the reigning champion off his perch by then. But that doesn’t mean I won’t activate my little high tech nano wings and glide back round.

2 Likes

If I remember correctly TreeCreator was on open source project in the beginning. If it’s the same project. If you guys really plan to abandon it, better give it back to community, I am sure there will be some peoples around to can work on.

I still don’t understand the real reason why you guys do that.

i can understand, third part software is not unity’s business… this tool is typically a third part affair.
less work, less bugs, less complaints…
i wish they put their energy on providing an awesome terrain system, THAT matters.

3 Likes