tvOS 13 - No Horizontal on Controller when on Apple TV

ok pulling my hair out
No Horizontal on Controller when running game on Apple TV
Vertical all works and buttons

in unity (2019.3 7f1) works perfectly and on remote 5 on Apple TV with nimbus controller connected to Apple TV
but when i build the game and put it on Apple TV no Horizontal ??? vertical and buttons work fine ???

what I’m i missing ???

Did you ever make a bug report for this?

no i didn’t … because wasn’t sure if it was something i was doing wrong or the software