VRChat Prop won't turn off when I add a moving parts animation

So I’m trying to recreate the music box from sea of thieves. I have 3 animation files total. 2 to turn the Music Box off and on in the hierarchy (‘MusicBox’ layer) and the other moves the pieces of the music box (MusicBoxAnim layer)

The box works but after it’s toggled on I can’t toggle it off and when I click the toggle in the expressions menu it doesn’t do anything. The only thing that works is actually resetting the avatar. I should note that the On/Off animations work when the moving parts are disabled or deleted from the layers