Game Dev: Is It Really What You Want To Do? Why?

Objective achieved :slight_smile:

1 Like

I’m only in it for the women, but that’s not on the poll

3 Likes

I don’t see an option for ā€œYes, but not for ten hours everyday if I don’t feel like it, and I’m my own bossā€?

Oh wait, I guess I’m echoing a previous post :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

OK Cliffy B :wink:

I’m not sure I really want to know, but anyway how’s that working out for ya?

1 Like

Not great, but it may be for certain reasons

3 Likes

I most likely won’t continue doing it after I release this title. Way too much work.

But I gotta get this mofo done already, good lord. Fighting an uphill battle against the odds is fun and all, but I am pretty done with having to compromise all the time, finding work arounds for everything, trying to find some way to work a narrative around limited, often crappy art, etc.

The work itself isn’t bad, but being wildly, wildly under funded and having to scramble constantly and jerry rig everything is just too annoying.

2 Likes

LMAO, the ultimate way to be a misanthrope… Don’t shower.

@frosted

I’ll shorten this down… Changing a camera perspective can make all the difference. In terms of art quality, time needed, optimisation, expectation and complexity etc.

For e.g. a top down game like torchlight is much more ā€œcoderā€ focussed than my Sci-Fi FPS thingy or your 3D thingy (no innuendo there).

If you’re working in a small team or as a lone dev, you’ve got to be kind of multi-talented these days. I wonder how far you can actually get in a 3D FPS / RPG without being at least competent in terms of art?

I say no matter the challenge give it a proper go, it’s all part of the journey.

1 Like

It gets better ! Or so I’ve been told.
You might get a post launch rush that keeps you coming back -
Your next idea that pushes you to form a small team where you regularly are managing people coming and going cleaning up content, and moving forward while doing the same stuff, but with more experience doing it.
Then post launch rush -
next idea
…
…
…
.

2 Likes

The only way I would consider another game is if I make a dump truck full of money and can hire a good artist full time for the duration.

Otherwise there are just too many dumb and unfortunate compromises.

It’s just not really worth the huge time investment unless you can produce something high quality, and realistically without a skilled, dedicated, professional team the quality suffers too much. So either I’ll use the game as portfolio piece to join a company that’s hopefully doing good work, or I maybe back to writing trading systems or something.

What I really want to do is have lots of money and get tons of ego-fuel from my adoring fan base. And if that’s wrong, then I don’t want to be right.

2 Likes

#1 priority for me is eventually working for myself. I don’t feel like as you get older you can rely on stable employment, seen too many companies axe my friends during RIFs and watch them scramble to get new crappy jobs until they are just kind of biding time until retirement at jobs they hate.

I’m working on #1(not gamedev though gaming related). I think gamedev as a hobby probably suits me better because quite honestly I would quit after the first crunch I hear about in that world. Been there done that, now I’ve got a kid and other crap to do besides work. True solo indie gamedev would interest me but I don’t think I could support myself on it, so maybe the question is do you want to do gamedev for others or for yourself.

3 Likes

I’ve spoken to Sara about this (I’ve been in Copenhagen this week getting up to speed!) and we agree it’s an interesting point and something we may consider for the forum overhaul in the future. I don’t want to make promises but we will at the very least discuss it :slight_smile:

In the mean time, if someone would like to start a thread to contain biz talk in General Discussion, we can make it into a pinned post.

3 Likes

I write a game because I always wanted to write a game, don’t expect to make much money with it, I just want it to be something unique that people would want to play.

4 Likes

But while everyone was making games. Our robots slaves would take care of all the manual labour so it would all be fine?

Funnily enough, I watched a Star Trek episode where they’d become so technically advanced stories were a form of currency. Maybe it’ll get to that point eventually?

The deed is done.

Like anything, it depends on where you work, and at what level. It is still a creative industry, not an assembly line. Certainly on the massive games there are entry level type positions, but if you don’t have experience, you have to start somewhere. If you are at professional level, there really aren’t ā€˜bosses’ breathing down your neck, at least not in a traditional sense. Certainly there are producers and project managers who keep track of schedules and progress, but their role is more to facilitate the developers.

To better illustrate, here is how I (we) work:
We do two week sprints, meaning we plan everything basically two weeks at a time. (Anything bigger than two weeks is broken up.) At the beginning of each sprint each pod and/or discipline meet to plan and divide up the tasks. Any task that I take on, I provide a time estimate and any requirements. I take on roughly 60 hours of work, leaving another 20 for padding, meetings and fires. (it’s never perfect). We do have to meet deadlines, but we are the ones who determine those deadlines. (in that way, it is similar to contracting, we provide an estimate and are expected to deliver on that estimate) If there is too much that is unknown, and can’t give an accurate estimate, then we have to plan time to do exploration/prototyping to find out how it will be done. (a lot of my work involves of that) If anything goes sideways, or I get blocked, my producer is there to sort it out. At the end of the day, we all have the same goal. It’s much like any other professional creative job, we’re not punching a time-clock and warming seats. We are paid to be creative. Our team picks the projects we do, and have pretty much full control over them. Though since the are all IP based, art and story have to be approved by the teams that own them. But we have been working with them long enough, that it is rarely an issue.

I’ve done the indie thing, small teams/studios and large. All have been good times. In the rare cases they weren’t, I left. I never saw the point in doing something or staying somewhere I didn’t enjoy. My current team are some the most fantasic people, some I have known and worked with on and off with for over a decade. For this kind of work, its all about your team. Sure, some days are rough, but in context, it’s pretty hard to complain too seriously.

For me, it is as @aer0ace said, it’s is my passion. I can’t say I ā€˜love’ every single minute of it, but who can say that about anything? I love the work, and it constantly varies. Sometimes several times a day. This job is not only is a great fit for my ADHD, it often relies on it. :wink: I started my career as an artist(print/advertising), and bounced back and forth that and software development. Games are wonderful because they let me do both. And I get to teach game development, both to kids (several times a year), and to co-workers who want to learn more about the other disciplines.

I’ve been doing this professionally for over two decades, and simply can’t imagine doing anything else.

8 Likes

This is actually great, because this is complementary to my other post. I had forgotten to talk about my previous experience at the AAA studio, and this pretty much describes that. It’s always more about the people you work with than it is the actual work. It makes going through Alpha, Beta, and Final that much more endurable. What’s funny, is I always treated working at that studio as a ā€œstepping stoneā€, just because of the exposure of working with brilliant minds, and other creative thinkers, and that in itself pretty much kept me there for 10 years. Especially near the end of the development cycle, when the game already shipped and you start working on an expansion pack which isn’t the most exciting thing in the world.

I wanted to separate those two experiences, because my first post was all about ā€œgoing indieā€, and @GarBenjamin grouped the two together, as if the reasons to work in the game industry would be the same. Well, in that sense, @zombiegorilla linked passion as being the common quality that game developers have towards their craft.

5 Likes

Yes I’ve heard of that before @zombiegorilla , I believe it is the ā€˜scrum’ workflow which yields the best results for game dev.
It sounds interesting almost like mini burnouts but it has advantages over the let’s carefully plan the thing from start to finish, where you can end up near the end with something that needs to completely rewritten or changed.

Can an indie doing that by themselves stick with such a deadline, or goal without any real motivation? Especially from nobody else.

@Ony if you would like to share your experiences, preferably something other than for the $$$ :wink:

Thanks